Jane Adams, Faner 3539 Office hours: 3:00-4:30 MWF and by appointment
Phone 453-5019 email: jadams@siu.edu
This course deals with the ways people form collective, or cultural, identities. It focuses on North America. After an introduction to the main ideas, we will discuss four major ways people form collective identities: through religion, through nationalism, through race, and through class. We will find that these primary axes of cultural difference overlap in unpredictable ways, and that other axes of difference, especially gender, make people’s experiences widely different from one another.
ORGANIZATION OF THE COURSE:
We begin with an orientation to the issues involved, then take up religion through reading Anthony F.C. Wallace’s study of the Handsome Lake Religion.
Anthony F.C. Wallace, Death and Rebirth of the Seneca, Random House, 1972 (Vintage).
We then move to issues of national or ethnic identity, beginning with a philosophical article on the nature of national identity, “Culture, National Identity, and Admission to Citizenship” by Shelley Wilcox. The class will divide into two parts, with each reading one of two books:
Karen Isaksen Leonard, Making Ethnic Choices: California’s Punjabi Mexican Americans.
Philadelphia
:
Temple
University
Press, 1994.
Celeste Ray,
Highland
Heritage: Scottish Americans in the American South. Chapel Hill:
University
of
North Carolina
Press, 2000.
The third unit, on race, ties directly into my current research. We will view and discuss the video I produced with D. Gorton. The class will again divide into two parts, with each reading one of two books:
John Jackson, Harlemworld: Doing Race and Class in Contemporary Black
America
.
Chicago
: The
University
of
Chicago
Press, 2003.
Carol Stack, Call to Home: African Americans Reclaim the Rural South. Basic Books, 1996.
The fourth unit deals with class, one of the most theoretically problematic categories in the contemporary period. We will address it in the context of race, with the entire class reading an article about working class whites in the Mississippi Delta by myself and D. Gorton, “Confederate Lane,” and one of two books,
John Hartigan, Jr., Racial Situations: Class Predicaments of Whiteness in
Detroit
.
Princeton
University
Press, 1999.
Kirby Moss, The Color of Class: Poor Whites and the Paradox of Privilege.
University
of
Pennsylvania
Press, 2003.
Two recent ethnographies are assigned for three of the units. In these units, the following procedure will occur:
- You will be assigned one of the two ethnographies. If you would rather read the other one, you are responsible for trading assignments with one of your classmates.
- Locate all the reviews possible of the book you are assigned in scholarly journals (check Ebsco, JSTOR, AnthroSource, and google.com). Print out these reviews.
- The first and second weeks of the unit, you will meet with your classmates who are reading the same ethnography. These groups will function as a seminar discussing the book. You will be given a set of discussion questions to discuss in your group. I will meet with each group to help clarify and contextualize information in your book.
- The third week each group will report on their book to their classmates. Suggested format, with each topic given by different members of the group: a) General description of the book; b) Overview of the reviews; c) Theoretical issues; d) Methodology used; e) other as relevant. Turn in notes used for oral presentation.
REQUIREMENTS:
1. Attendance: The content of this course is based on student participation. Attendance is therefore critical. Students are required to attend all classes. You are allowed three (3) absences without penalty. YOU WILL LOSE 1/3 (ONE-THIRD) LETTER GRADE FOR EACH CLASS YOU MISS IN EXCESS OF THREE ABSENCES.
2. Reading: You will read four ethnographies and associated articles.
3. Short summaries. You will write a short (1 page, 250 words) response piece to each reading, as assigned. These response pieces will be due in class the on the day assigned.
4. Reports. You will be responsible for reporting on the books you are assigned, as part of your group.
5. Term paper. You will write a term paper on a topic relevant to the theme of the course. Under-graduate papers will be 12-15 pages (3,000 to 4,000 words), graduate papers 20-25 pages (5,000 to 7,000 words). Select your topic by the 3rd week, hand in a preliminary bibliography week 8, consult with Dr. Adams, week 9, paper due week 14. You may, in close consultation with Dr. Adams, do a piece of creative work creative writing, web site, video, or other work.
Style for your paper:
Basic bibliographic style
American Anthropologist style guide (Style for all contingencies)
6. Exams. There will be a midterm and a final take home exam.
7. Grading:
| Midterm |
20%
|
| Final |
30%
|
| Term paper |
30%
|
| Summaries & Oral Report |
20%
|
|
100%
|
Academic Dishonesty: We welcome you to this classroom community with the assumption that the work you do will be your own. However, distinguishing your work from the work of another can be tricky at times, for both you and your instructor. Presenting another’s work as your own, even if by accident, is a serious violation of the Student Conduct Code.
The Student Conduct Code identifies the following as acts of academic dishonesty: Plagiarism, representing the work of another as ones own work; preparing work for another that is to be used as that persons own work; cheating by any method or means; &soliciting, aiding, abetting, concealing, or attempting conduct in violation of this code (p. 18).
Whether quoting or paraphrasing (or even summarizing) someone else’s work, you should cite your sources. Failure to do so constitutes an act of plagiarism. This policy applies to papers and speeches. Buying a paper online, copying text from several web sites, and turning in someone else’s paper (even with a few words changed) are all examples of plagiarism when you claim such work as your own.
Note: As services selling such papers have increased in number, so have services that track plagiarism using sources from the internet.
Suspected cases of plagiarism will be investigated following Article V of the Student Conduct Code. If plagiarism is substantiated, the perpetrator may face failing the assignment, failing the course, disciplinary censure, and/or suspension from the university, depending on the details of the case (see Article III of the Student Conduct Code).
Rule of thumb: when in doubt, cite where the information is coming from. If you are uncertain whether you are citing sources sufficiently and appropriately enough to avoid plagiarism, please consult your instructor or a tutor at the Writing Center.
Emergency Procedures: Southern Illinois University
Carbondale
is committed to providing a safe and healthy environment for study and work. Because some health and safety circumstances are beyond our control, we ask that you become familiar with the SIUC Emergency Response Plan and Building Emergency Response Team (BERT) program. Emergency response information is available on posters in buildings on campus, available on the BERT'S website at www.bert.siu.edu , Department of Public Safety's website www.dps.siu.edu (disaster drop down) and in the Emergency Response Guidelines pamphlet. Know how to respond to each type of emergency.
Instructors will provide guidance and direction to students in the classroom in the event of an emergency affecting your location. It is important that you follow these instructions and stay with your instructor during an evacuation or sheltering emergency. The Building Emergency Response Team will provide assistance to your instructor in evacuating the building or sheltering within the facility.
SCHEDULE OF CLASSES
|
Week 1
Aug. 20
|
Monday lesson on how to use the on-line library.
Wednesday - Discuss Gilda Laura Ochoa, “Mexican Americans’ Attitudes toward and Interactions with Mexican Immigrants: A Qualitative Analysis of Conflict and Cooperation.” Social Science Quarterly 81(1):84-105, March 2000. [EBSCO]
Friday - Continue discussion of identity, etc.
LINK TO NOTES |
|
Week 2 Aug. 27
|
Monday Find one article that deals with issues of collective or cultural identity in a North American context. Email author/title/journal url to me, and to rest of class, by Sunday evening. jadams@siu.edu. Come to class with a brief statement (250 words) of what the article says about collective or cultural identity. Use this form:
- Author, Title, Source, Date, page numbers (bibliographic citation form)
- Your name
- “This paper is about” a brief summary of who, what, when, where the article deals with.
- What the article says about issues of collective or cultural identity.
Wednesday - Continue discussion in light of your readings.
Friday - Begin unit on religion [summary of Part I due]
Wallace, Death and Rebirth of the Seneca. Part I. The Heyday of the Iroquois
LINK TO PowerPoint CHAPTER 1
|
|
Week 3
Sept. 3
|
Monday -Labor Day No Class
Wednesday & Friday: Wallace, Death and Rebirth of the Seneca cont. Part I
Summaries of each chapter due on day chapter is discussed
LINK TO PowerPoint CHAPTER 2
NOTES TO CHAPTER 3 & 4
Friday: Turn in topic for term paper.
|
|
Week 4
Sept. 10
|
Wallace, Anthony F.C., Death and Rebirth of the Seneca.
Summaries of each chapter due on day chapter is discussed
LINK TO PowerPoint TO CHAPTER 5
LINK TO PowerPoint TO CHAPTER 6
LINK TO PowerPoint TO CHAPTER 7
|
|
Week 5
Sept. 17
|
Wallace, Anthony F.C., Death and Rebirth of the Seneca.
Summaries of each chapter due on day chapter is discussed
LINK TO PowerPoint TO CHAPTER 8
LINK TO PowerPoint TO CHAPTER 9
LINK TO PowerPoint TO CHAPTER 10
|
|
Week 6
Sept. 24
|
Begin unit on national and ethnic identities.
Get reviews of assigned book for Wednesday discussion. Read book.
Read for your assigned book: Karen Isaksen Leonard, Making Ethnic Choices:
California
’s Punjabi Mexican Americans.
Chapter 1 | Chapter 2 | Chapter 3 | Chapter 4 | Chapter 5 | Chapter 6 | Chapter 7 | Chapter 8 | Chapter 9 | Chapter 10 | Chapter 11 | Class Presentation | PowerPoint images & maps from 2005
Celeste Ray,
Highland
Heritage: Scottish Americans in the American South.
Chapter 1 | Chapter 2 | Chapter 3 | Chapter 4 | Chapter 5 | Chapter 6 | Chapter 7 | Class Presentation | Maps of Scots in America
Monday: Begin discussing books. See Instructions here.
PDF here
Bibliography due in class Friday.
|
Week 7
Oct. 1
|
Continue discussion of books.
Meet with Dr. Adams to discuss paper.
|
|
Week 8, Oct. 8
|
Monday: Report on Making Ethnic Choices Notes & reviews due
Wednesday: Report on Highland Heritage Notes & reviews due
Friday: General discussion and review
|
|
Week 9,
Oct. 15
|
Monday: MIDTERM
Begin unit on race.
Wednesday: Race:Mississippi. Video and materials on web. http://www.siu.edu/~jadams/mississippi_delta/mj_frame.html
Friday: Read and find reviews for your assigned book
John Jackson. Harlemworld: Doing Race and Class in Contemporary Black
America
.
Notes from in-class discussion, Introduction
Harlemworld 1
Carol Stack, Call to Home: African Americans Reclaim the Rural South.
Kinship - Burdy's Bend, South Carolina
Notes Chaps 1-5
Notes on Chaps. 6-8
|
|
Weeks 10
Oct 22
|
Continue discussion of book.
|
|
Week 11
Oct. 29
|
Monday: Report on Harlemworld Notes & reviews due
Wednesday: Report on Call to Home Notes & reviews due
Friday: General discussion
|
|
Week 12 Nov. 5
|
Begin unit on class.
Get reviews of assigned book for Wednesday discussion. Read book.
Monday: Confederate Lane: Class, race and ethnicity in the Mississippi Delta. by Jane Adams and D. Gorton. American Ethnologist 33(2): 288-309 Summary due.
Begin reading
Wednesday and Friday: Discussion of
John Hartigan, Jr. Racial Situations: Class Predicaments of Whiteness in
Detroit
.
Kirby Moss, The Color of Class: Poor Whites and the Paradox of Privilege.
Hartigan & Moss, 1st lecture
Hartigan & Moss, 2nd lecture
Moss, Chaps. 5-8
Hartigan & Moss, Theoretical considerations
|
|
Week 13 Nov. 12
|
Monday, Wednesday, Friday: Discuss books
Term paper due in class Friday.
|
|
Week 14 Nov 19
|
Thanksgiving Break
|
|
Week 15 Nov. 26
|
Monday: Report on Racial Situations
Wednesday: Report on The Color of Class
Friday: General discussion
|
|
Week 16
Dec. 3
|
Sum up course. Review.
|
Week 17
Dec. 14
12:50. 2:50 p.m |
Final Exam due. Come to class during final exam period to discuss your answers to the final exam questions. |
|
|